Can You Forgive Her? by Anthony Trollope

“Whether or no, she, whom you are to forgive, if you can, did or did not belong to the Upper Ten Thousand of this our English world, I am not prepared to say with any strength of affirmation.”

And so starts the first book of the Palliser series, Can You Forgiver Her? (1865), to be followed by:

  • Phineas Finn (1869)
  • The Eustace Diamonds  (1873)
  • Phineas Redux (1874)
  • The Prime Minister (1876)
  • The Duke’s Children (1880)

 

Previously known as the Parliamentary novels, the novels encompass a number of literary genres but also seem to highlight the corruption of British parliamentary politicians.  In his autobiography, Trollope said of this series:

“To carry out my scheme I have had to spread my picture over so wide a canvas that I cannot expect that any lover of such art should trouble himself to look at it as a whole. Who will read Can You Forgive Her?, Phineas Finn, Phineas Redux, and The Prime Minister consecutively, in order that they may understand the characters of the Duke of Omnium, of Plantagenet Palliser, and of Lady Glencora? Who will ever know that they should be so read?”

I plan to answer Trollope’s direction and read all of the books consecutively, so here I go ….

Characters:

Alice Vavasor – wealthy, stubborn and independent; in her mid-twenties

John Grey – a saintly intelligent farmer who wants to marry Alice; eventually an MP

George Vavasor – Alice’s cousin and her first love but he broke her heart over some unexplained peccadillo; now he plays with her heart again; his character is questionable

Kate Vavasor – the sister of George and cousin to Alice; she is Alice’s friends but has an unreasonable loyalty to her brother.

John Vavasor – Alice’s father; has little influence over her but is sensible

Lady Glencora – set to marry Plantagenet Palliser if her own bad judgement doesn’t overcome her good sense.

Burgo Fitzgerald – Lady Glencora’s first love but a complete rake and untrustworthy person

Plantagenet Palliser – a rather uninteresting man, however he shows exceptional understanding and patient love

Mrs. Arabella Greenow – the aunt of Alice who has inherited wealth from her husband and is part of a comedy of courting by two suitors, Mr. Samuel Cheesacre and Captain Gustavus Bellfield.

__________________

Alice Vavasor is engaged to a wealthy, respectable, stable man named John Grey. Previously she was engaged to her cousin, George Vavasor, but she broke it off due to some unexplained peccadillo of George’s.  Yet in spite of John Grey’s very estimable character, Alice suddenly decides that she could not bear to be married to a country gentlemen and shrinks at what she thinks may be expected of her. George’s sister, Kate, wishes for Alice and George to pick up their romance again and when the three cousins take a holiday tour in Switzerland, Alice returns and breaks her engagement with John Grey.

Basel

Yet in spite of all Alice’s relatives being horrified by her decision, Alice finds herself attracted to the parliamentary life George may lead as he plans to run for a seat.  Receiving a proposal letter from him, Alice accepts both his offer and his candid revelation that she will be expected to bankroll all his political aspirations.

Yet, John Grey, patient and for some completely puzzling reason, in love with this capricious woman, resolves to wait patiently for her and nothing short of her marriage to another will sway him from his course.

Concurrently, Glencora Palliser begins a friendship with Alice.  They are cousins and once, when Glencora meant to run away with a thoroughly unsuitable, wastrel named Burgo Fitzgerald, Alice refused to help her ruin herself, which resulted in Glencora being forced to marry Plantagenet Palliser, an incredibly rich aristocrat and politician who is in line to become Chancellor of the Exchequer.  Glencora is still sillily and overwhelmingly in love with Burgo who attempts to get her to run away with him.  Her husband exhibits saint-like patience with her unaristocratic behaviour and ridiculous whims.

As the novel progresses, one wonders why Trollope is presenting two such silly women and two such virtuous, tolerant, imperturbable men.  It made me understand why men might choose to lock up their wives or restrict their movements, lol!  And if only men like that existed!

But all was wrapped up handily in the end with Alice overly penitent and Glencora moderated, but still exhibiting that frank and impetuous character that made her both extremely frustrating and quite loveable.

Of Can You Forgive Her?, Trollope said:

“Of Can You Forgive Her? I cannot speak with too great affection, though I do not know that of itself it did very much to increase my reputation. As regards the story, it was formed chiefly on that of the play …’The Noble Jilt.’ …The humourous characters, which are also taken from the play … are well done. But that which endears the book to me is the first presentation which I made in it of Plantagenet Palliser, with his wife, Lady Glencora.”

Note: In Trollope’s Barchestershire series, Plantagenet Palliser made a short appearance in The Small House at Allington.  He is the heir to the Duke of Omnium.

 

 

One thought on “Can You Forgive Her? by Anthony Trollope”

  1. I read this and the other Palliser novels many, many years ago, when I was in the midst of a major Trollope binge (oddly enough, I’ve recently been considering a re-read of Can You Forgive her?). It really was a wonderful reading project, as all the novels feature some great characters, and Trollope really is a gifted story teller.
    Although I liked all the novels, naturally some resonated more than others. My least favorites were the ones that had the most politics, i.e., the two Phineas novels (particularly Phineas Finn) and The Prime Minister. The Eustace Diamonds is a nice, almost standalone novel in the series. Although it has some Palliser characters (mostly in the background) and is set in the same world, it’s more of a Victorian mystery type novel. As I recall, I liked it a great deal.

Thanks for visiting. I'd love to hear from you and have you join in the discussion!