“Winter! Who ever heard of such a name?”
|The ruins of the Residency at Lucknow and the
gunfire it received
This historical aspect of this novel was fascinating. Kaye communicated the various personages and political posturing in a highly realistic manner, from the blind stubbornness of the British commanders, to the insightful planning of Sir Henry Lawrence; from the rebel attacks in Delhi, to the flight of the British characters in their attempts to escape the carnage, the reader is treated to a highly developed and suspenseful plot that keeps him riveted to the pages. Kaye also weaves a descriptive masterpiece of the settings of India and one can feel the heat radiating from the land, hear the chatter of the people in the bazaars, sense the tension between races and the suppressed passion between Winter and Alex Randall.
|The Sepoy revolt at Meerut
from Illustrated London News, 1857
Sadly, the romance in the novel was the most disappointing part. Randall appeared rather self-absorbed for the greater part of the book, his job and political responsibilities often overshadowing any love or caring or attention that he could have shown Winter, and the uncomfortableness of her situation (a married woman) combined with Randall’s independent and sometimes abrasive character quelled any feelings of satisfaction that might have been generated by their love story. Winter also had a penchant for overreacting with an exaggerated response that would cause her to make unwise decisions which would either damage her position, or needlessly complicate her life. While it perhaps added to the plot, it was often annoying and not necessarily believable. Randall himself displayed a character that was not particularly warm or generous towards women; I could understand Winter’s attraction to him, but I also thought their future life would be fraught with discontent and unrest, very much like the India they inhabited.
Here is an article written by M.M. Kaye on her writing of Shadow of the Moon, which I found interesting and illuminating. In spite of a few reservations about the romance aspect, the rest of the novel was highly enjoyable and I thank Cirtnecce for her read-along. If you want to read more about the book and the Indian Sepoy mutiny, please see her post on the Company Raj and her post on The Landscape of the Mutiny.