Wuthering Heights Read-Along Week #1

Wuthering Heights is one of the few Brönte novels that I have not read and, in spite of previously feeling somewhat ambivalent towards this book, I’m looking forward to it for this read-along hosted by Maggie at An American in France blog.

Chapters 1 – 9

Wuthering Heights begins in media res, with Mr. Lockwood visiting his landlord, Heathcliff at his home, Wuthering Heights.  While initially curious about Heathcliff’s strange means of living and intrigued by his caustic manner, his second visit arouses a much altered response.  Treated to disrespectful treatment by the servants, occupants and master alike, he is dismayed to find himself an overnight guest courtesy of a snowstorm.  While in his room that night, Lockwood has a horrifying dream that ends with a young girl named Catherine Linton (yet he has also seen her name scratched on the windowsill as Catherine Earnshaw and Catherine Heathcliff) grasping his hand through the window and begging to be let in.  His cry summons Heathcliff who, pale as death, agrees with Lockwood’s decision to leave early and as Lockwood leaves the room, Heathcliff calls out in despair to his “Cathy”.  Later Lockwood is told the story of the Earnshaw family: how Heathcliff was brought home by Master Earnshaw from the streets of Liverpool and brought up within the family, although both the wife and brother hated his presence, while Catherine, the daughter, eventually chose him for a constant companion.  We learn of Heathcliff’s dark, silent suffering that perhaps conceals more than we have yet seen, and of Catherine’s willful, selfish spirit, each negative quality of these characters, nurtured by the lonely, loveless environment in which they live, and the harsh or indifferent treatment they receive from the father, mother and especially Hindley, Catherine’s brother, who becomes their guardian after the parents’ deaths.  At the end of chapter 9, Catherine has agreed to marry Edgar Linton, a son of a respectable family, yet she vows a lifelong faithfulness to Heathcliff and a desire to enhance his life by her new respectable and influential position.  Given Heathcliff’s sullen pride, dark brooding tempers and possessive inclinations towards her, one wonders how she can justify her decision using such an untenable explanation.

Photo courtesy of Steve Calcott (source Flickr)
Creative Commons License

What connects the reader to the two main characters of the novel?  So far neither have engaged my admiration but I think we can all feel a silent sympathy for their plight.  Their sheltered lives, amongst people who failed to nurture even a sentiment of human feeling in either character, evoke a tentative compassion, as their choices seem to have already been made for them, instead of being products of stable, empathetic temperments.  The tension at the end of the chapter is palpable, as a shocking car wreck that we cannot look away from, the foreshadowing of intensity of the coming situation evident.

And so we continue ………… can Catherine convince Heathcliff of the merits of her marriage?  Will she be happy?  Or will Heathcliff instead chose a destructive path that will affect more people than just himself?  ………  

Read-along posts:  Chapters 1-9 / Chapters 10-17 / Chapters 18-26 / Chapters 27-34 / FINAL REVIEW

6 thoughts on “Wuthering Heights Read-Along Week #1

  1. "A shocking car wreck that we cannot look away from," YESSS. That's a great simile. It's hard to like Catherine and Heathcliff (it's easier to pity them), but at the same time I still want to know what happens to them. This is one of the few novels I've read that has me intrigued by the plot despite the fact that I do not like the main characters!

    I tried to comment on your post earlier this week, but it wouldn't let me for some reason 🙁 I look forward to your thoughts on the next section! I stayed up late finishing it last night… – Maggie @ An American in France

  2. I've almost finished the next section too. Wow! In some ways it's surprising and in other ways, not. I wonder what you think about it! I'll be watching for your post, Maggie!

  3. I felt some degree of sympathy for Heathcliff by the end of Chapter 9, but it disappeared by the end of Chapter 17. Wuthering Heights is definitely a "shocking car wreck."

  4. Me, too, but I think my sympathy waned earlier than yours did. I keep reading and wondering "can it get any worse?" Fortunately I have a theory as to why Catherine was so tied to him, otherwise I think I would have been pulling my hair out. In fact, I think the actions of most of the characters of the story are believable given the circumstances, but I do question the validity of the circumstances. Well, onward and upward …… I hope …..!

  5. So far you have made a great commentary of this book. I think the isolation did nurture a lot of the aberrant behavior that we see in Heathcliff and Katherine. It makes me think of the hillbillies of the Smokies and the lawlessness that reigned there.

  6. This was early in the read, when I was still engaged with the book. Somewhere it went off the rails for me. I do see the hillbilly similarities, with people being a law unto themselves and families being almost a kingdom within themselves.

Thanks for visiting. I'd love to hear from you and have you join in the discussion!