Daniel Deronda by George Eliot

“Was she beautiful or not beautiful?”

Gwendolyn Harleth is a “spoiled child”, a young woman with average prospects yet with high hopes of attaining respectable social standing and monetary comfort. While scorning the traditional avenues of marriage, she desperately wishes for a meaningful, vibrant life, even though she is unsure of how to attain it.  Gambling, parties and equestrian amusements, fill her time, with little thought of other peoples wants, needs or struggles.

Daniel Deronda is a respectable moral young man and the ward of Sir Hugo Mallinger.  When he first spies Gwendolyn, his disapproval of her gambling and later, the same quiet censure of some of her actions, leads her down a path of introspection and causes her to question the manner in which she is living her life.  Yet the changes in her character do not come soon enough and, due to her family’s sudden monetary troubles, she contracts a marriage to Henleigh Mallinger Grandcourt, the nephew and heir of Sir Hugo.  She views the marriage as an escape from poverty and a stepping stone to a life of leisure and a respectable position in society.  Instead she gets a husband with a twisted soul, bent on breaking her will as he would a horse or a wild animal.  He glories in her struggles, fear and his ability to control her actions.

Gwendolyn at the Roulette Table

A second plot winds itself through Gwendolyn’s, as Deronda internally questions the manner of his birth and the identity of his parents.  Not wishing to bring up a subject that may be uncomfortable for Sir Hugo, he suppresses his curiosity, yet aches for familial connections and history.  Upon saving a Jewish singer from drowning, his relationship with her takes him down the path of finding his true heritage.

Eliot forces the reader to examine some of the social issues of that time.  Without money, young women could only hope to find work in low paying positions, such as governesses or companions, or perhaps choose less respectful avenues as singers or actresses.  Without an inheritance or a family who was financially able to support them, an advantageous marriage was really the only protection for women of this time period.

She also treats the subject of Jewish identity and culture with surprising dexterity and perception.  While they are portrayed with an obvious sympathy, Eliot makes each character real, from the philosophic and idealistic Mordecai, to the money-loving pawnbroker, Cohen. The struggle of a people against prejudice and pre-judgement is plainly explored with touching sincerity and insight.  Mordecai’s longing to see the Zionist hopes for a Jewish homeland established adds a deeper more complex examination of an issue that was of particular interest to the author.

The Fair Toxophilites (Archers)
by William Firth (1872)
Wikimedia Commons

I found that certain parts of the novel dragged, and the plot suffered numerous bumps, but again Eliot tackled such diverse issues, making the writing of the novel an epic task, so I can forgive some of the inconsistencies. Her obvious intellectual curiosity, and her enlightened opinions made the read informative as well as enjoyable.  Daniel Deronda is a book that prods you to think and ponder even after the last page is turned.

“In the chequered area of human experience the seasons are all mingled as in the golden age: fruit  and blossom hang together,; in the same moment the sickle is reaping and the seed is sprinkled; one tends the green cluster and another treads the wine-press.  Nay, in each of our lives harvest and spring-time are continually one, until Death himself gathers us and sows us anew in his invisible fields.”

7 thoughts on “Daniel Deronda by George Eliot

  1. I find Eliot's plots often are a little clunky but I think it's unavoidable because she covers so many issues and usually has such a large cast of characters. It doesn't take away from the book though and, in fact, is something particular about her writing style that I've learned to expect and enjoy.

    Some critics of this book wish that she had left out the plot line involving the Jews, but then we would have been left following the life of a spoilt young woman with a "damaged" view of life. Even if she changed during the novel, it would have been much less interesting without the issues of the treatment of Jews in England and their longing for a homeland.

    Glad I can be of service! 😀

  2. I read Silas Marner last year and liked it so much more than I thought I would! So far that's the only George Eliot novel I've read, but I have The Mill on the Floss on my list for sometime this year. In the small amount of research I've done on her novels, Daniel Deronda sounded like it could be one of her more interesting ones. Great post!

  3. I haven't read The Mill on the Floss, but I've heard that it's very good. Other than this book, I've read both Middlemarch and Silas Marner (but SM a long time ago). You really can't go wrong with Eliot. She hasn't disappointed me yet.

    Thanks for your kind words!

  4. You're welcome, Emily. I love her writing too! She has such interesting ideas and some delightful quirks. I think she would have been a very fascinating person to know. It would be interesting to read a biography about her life.

  5. Pingback: The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot - Classical CarouselClassical Carousel

Thanks for visiting. I'd love to hear from you and have you join in the discussion!